Jan 31st 2012, 10:17 by N.B. | WASHINGTON, D.C.
DRINKERS of the world, today I'm pointing you to this blog post from the Atlantic's James Fallows, who offers what is probably my favourite travel tip of all time. It meets all the criteria for a great tip: it's not totally obvious, you don't see people doing it all the time, it saves you money, it can make travel a little more fun, and it offers some of the satisfaction most of us get from flouting authority just a wee bit. You can thank me (and Mr Fallows) later. Here you go:
As someone that enjoys a drink as much or more than the next guy (and is also frugalish), the fluids rules for flying were a huge bummer for me because it was my practice for morning flights to build myself a nice big bloody mary in a disposable bottle for consumption as I passed my way through the security apparatus and inevitable downtime before the flight. Rather a good deal compared to the pathetic offerings for top dollar otherwise available to travelers.
Which brings me to my travel tip: Minis (the tiny little liquor bottles) happen to fit into your TSA quart sized baggie and are perfectly legal to take through security. A bottle of OJ on the far side of the line and you're in screwdriver heaven. Although, please be discrete as the US still has insane open container laws.
Which brings me to my story: Not long after I figured out this loophole, I tossed my baggie full of minis in the x-ray bin and the TSA screener looked at them and gave me a broad grin and said, "Now there's a man 'at knows how to fly." To which I could only grin and nod in agreement.
Let's say it again: there's a man who knows how to fly. Dean Martin and Dylan Thomas would be proud.
Now, since America's Transportation Security Administration (TSA) hates fun and merriment and America's airlines probably don't want you bringing your own drinks on board when you could be buying from them, it's important to be discreet about this travel tip. Don't bring 20 minis on the plane, get drunk, try to open the door mid-flight, and ruin it for everyone else. As they say in the adverts, please drink responsibly.
But if you follow the rules, this tip should allow you to mix your aeroplane drinks just how you like them (even in coach!) and save a few dollars, too. Until 2005, bizarre laws made South Carolina the world capital of miniature liquor bottles. In 2012, thanks to Mr Fallows's tip and the TSA's three-ounce rule, aircraft might take the title. Prost!
In this blog, our correspondents inform and entertain business travellers with news, views and reviews that help them make the most of life on the road. Sign up for our weekly "Gulliver's best" newsletter to have the blog's highlights delivered to your inbox »
Advertisement
Over the past five days
Over the past seven days
Advertisement
Readers' comments
The Economist welcomes your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful of other readers. Review our comments policy.
Sort:
Well, my way of flying is this:
1. avoid an America's airline at any cost. Their crews are 'angry birds' most times. Their meal is very expensive and inedible (sandwiches taste like cardboard) and they charge $7 a drink ($6 a can of lousy, watery beer).
2. Fly any Latin American airline, especially RTACA or COPA from Central America. They serve good rums in the Economy class and Flor de Cana 18-year old rum in Business. The other day I boarded a flight from San Salvador to San Jose, Costa Rica at 6:45 in the morning and a young and cotous stewardess offered me a cup of coffee, tea or a drink. What do you have, I asked. She answered, Grey Goose vodka, Chivas Regal 18yr old and Flor de Cana 18yr old. Tough choices I had to make in the early hours that day.
3. Drink responsibly and smile often.
Just to be clear, the possibility of getting arrested at the other end of your flight is very real. It happened to me! I was returning from 5 weeks in Afghanistan and on the 15 hour flight between Dubai and Washington DC, there was a lot of drinking going on. It wasn't being served by the attendants (as that cost money) but out of bottles that were presumably bought in the duty free in Dubai. When I got off the plane I was pulled aside and told I wasn't walking straight. I explained my day pack was very heavy and I was trying to put it on.. Long story short, I was put in a wheelchair, found just over the limit for alcohol in my system, and put in jail. I got out after about 6 hours as my husband was able to collect me, but not after a terrible freezing wait, no food, no shoes, no blanket, and a fine. I didn't have to go to court but was able later to just pay more money. In the end I learned a very important lesson.....Just get on the plane and go to sleep for the duration.
By all means, get drunk in flight. It will make it easier to push you out of the way as I scramble for the emergency exit when catastrophe strikes. (Also pinch the cash out of your wallet when you pass out).
Dear Gulliver, you are way behind the curve here. I learned this trick from my mom back in the early 90's when she used to wear a lei made of JD minis getting onto the plane. She got more than her fair share of 'savvy traveller' nods through the airport.
Seems to me that the passengers are revolting, though in the nicest possible way. The lesson though is that we get upset about restrictions which seem illogical and that we can easily find inconsisternies on the way in which the airlines and authorities treat the people who ultimatly pay their wages.
Americans are obsessed with alcohol. Everything revolves around alcohol and most stories start with: "Remember that time when we were wasting and....."
Someone should write a book titled "Alcohol nation"
Don't forget the chapter on Great Britian!
"we were wasting"
This is not standard American English, so I would be very surprised to learn that most stories begin this way.
"we were wasting"
This is not standard American English, so I would be very surprised to learn that most stories begin this way.
"please be discrete"
I try to move only in single, discrete steps when I am trying to be discreet.
at the end of the day, this is useful not because the author is telling you to drink on the plane, serving yourself. but there have been many times i've been stuck in airports due to delayed flights, weather ailments and other issues that have come up. Being stuck in an airport terminal for hours on end and having to pay $15-$18 and up for a single drink gets to be painful. i don't mind shelling out for drinks on the plane, $5 here, $5 there, that's nothing. but the ridiculously priced terminal bars, not going to happen. my two cents...use your head. drink responsibly. and let that be that.
So THAT's why many US airports hands passengers their Duty Free goods at the gates just before boarding, to stop them drinking the stuff in the terminals...
If you are going to be stuck for hours, find an airport lounge for $30 or so dollars and drink all you can drink while sitting in comfy chairs.
In many airports and jurisdictions this is illegal. Liquor laws hold on the ground at airports and even on board planes on the ground in the jurisdiction.
In many airports and jurisdictions this is illegal. Liquor laws hold on the ground, even at airports and on board planes on the ground.
i don't know what airports you fly out of but $30 will not get you far if you're stuck for hours. Least of all not lax, las or jfk.
@TonyVit at the end of the day, one is not saying to walk around with an open container or be sipping on a miniature bottle. i don't know what you mean my most airports and jurisdictions this is illegal? what is the exact thing you are claiming to be illegal? because if it's open container laws then yes i'll agree, but walking around an airport or having an alcoholic beverage in the terminal is by no means illegal. if that were the case, there wouldn't be any bars or alcoholic beverages served
It's not just that the airlines don't want you to "bring your own", it's against air law. It's illegal to drink alcohol on a plane unless served to you by the crew. That has to do with safety and passenger control.
Can you point us to this internationally accepted law? I can find no reference in anything from the International Civil Aviation Organization.
Yes, it's important to be discreet about this tip. Discreet like publishing it in the Economist. Sheesh.
Interesting that the "best travel tip ever" is about alcohol!
Maybe there should be a follow-up article about "best travel tipple ever"...
I just discovered that both ANA and JAL still serves FREE alcohol (Beer, Wine, Whisky, Gin, and Vodka) in Economy class for their European and American routes to and from Tokyo.
So, next time you are travelling coach to Japan, you know what airline to fly...
I just had a thought: Frequent travellers among us would no doubt have enough miles under their belts to warrant lounge access even when travelling coach, so what's to stop you bring an empty bottle of Evian, fill it with your favourite tipple in the Lounge, and then carry it all the way to your destination, for consumption at the other end?
I'll have to really check the small letters of the terms of lounge use to see if this works...
Actually, most mainline Asian carriers serve alcohol for free, even on regional flights, and definitely on transcontinental ones. It's only US airlines that are really, really cheap and ask you to pay for everything.
Perhaps because in the US people seated next to drunks, forced to deal with the inevitable results, will SUE or at least demand some kind of recompense.
Delta also serves free beer and wine to its steerage passengers traveling from the US to and from Japan (as of 3/2011), to Germany (12/2011) and from Switzerland (also 12/2011).
If I understand the legal distinctions, still seems like a good tip. Just do not make the drink in the terminal and make sure you ask the flight crew to serve you the alcohol once on the flight. I did not read any posts that precluded bringing properly contained alcohol onto an aircraft?
Seems the law is meant to give the flight crew control of the quantity of consumption which seems a reasonable restriction given the possible outcomes mentioned in other posts?
I'm surprised at all of the "but that's not legal" comments. There are plenty of flight attendants who turn blind eyes to these things. Some of us who are both frugal and frequent flyers order alcohol when in first class, take the mini bottles home with us, and then use them when flying in coach. A little discretion helps, but it is obvious that the flight attendants in first class are aware that we are taking the alcohol off the plane (which I've heard is not supposed to happen).
These days I fly much less often than I used to, so the cost of booze on flights isn't a significant item in my budget. I'd like to travel more; but, on the other hand, flying has become so tedious and unpleasant these days that it must be counted an ordeal.
I'm a flight attendant. This is ILLEGAL. Against federal law to serve yourself booze on an airplane.
You can bring a bottle on (a mini, or have a bottle delivered to you on board from a duty-free store, or buy a bottle at a wineshop inside security) and have a flight attendant serve you from it, which we are happy to do. But WE have to keep the bottle in the galley and we return it to you as you deplane.
If you're found pouring yourself drinks from minis in your zippy, or from any kind of bottle that is or which we suspect to be booze, you WILL be met by security when we land -- or we will divert (if you're a nuisance) and be faced with authorities wherever we divert. And yes, it DOES happen! YOU DON'T WANT TO DO THIS.
No. What will happen is the flight attendant will tell you that you're not allowed to do that, you'll say "really?" with a look of surprise, apologize, and nothing more will come of it. I've literally never seen this happen on a flight, and I've poured myself countless drinks. It never even occurred to me that it might be illegal, it's probably never occurred to 99% of passengers, and furthermore, we don't care. You are NOT going to call security to meet someone over a legitimate misunderstanding.
If I tell you the law and you don't stop, yes, I WILL call security. Because if I don't, then I'm the one in trouble right along with you. I never know who's watching me on a flight -- FAM, cabin safety inspectors (have them all the time, known to me and told about them afterward), non-revs who would love to rat me out. So I do not hesitate. The fines accrue to ME, not just to my airline. Don't think for a minute I will turn a blind eye to this. What if you get drunk and obnoxious and cause a scene? Then the question will be, "Why did you allow this to continue?" Passengers sitting nearby will tell authorities that I told the pax not to do this. If I don't enforce it to the best of my ability, I'm guilty too. That's how it works. The fact that you've gotten by with this doesn't mean you should continue to try it. And it certainly doesn't mean that you should encourage others to do so.
I never suggested ignoring the flight attendant.
The advice was to drink on the far side of security, not on the plane itself. Which is why the article said to be discrete.
"Which brings me to my travel tip: Minis (the tiny little liquor bottles) happen to fit into your TSA quart sized baggie and are perfectly legal to take through security. A bottle of OJ on the far side of the line and you're in screwdriver heaven. Although, please be discrete as the US still has insane open container laws."
You know we are the customer right?
Flying used to be fun.
Doesn't mean you can do as you wish. In fact, a huge part of my job is rule-enforcement.
It's a whole, WHOLE lot less fun when the alcoholic sitting next to you or your loved one drinks out of his ziplock full of minis or tipples from his duty-free bottle (delivered to him on board before take-off to a foreign city) and you get to spend 8-12 hours next to him.
Learn how to read. No one said they'd continue doing it once a flight attendant informed them it's illegal and asked them to stop.
But many, many people will -- and do. And I DO know how to read. I definitely know how to read my inflight manual, AND I'm aware of all the various liquor laws in the cities to which I fly -- which apply ON THE GROUND AT THE AIRPORT and ON BOARD PLANES ON THE GROUND AT THAT AIRPORT.
WHY ARE YOU YELLING? DOES THAT MAKE YOU FEEL LIKE YOU'RE RIGHT? Go lecture someone else. Your drivel is boring.
It might surprise you to learn that US Federal law does not apply to planes that neither take off, land, nor traverse the 190+ countries in the world that are not America.
If you follow the rules, you will find that this advice contravenes many open container and laws as well as federal statutes on the consumption of alcohol in public places and on board aircraft. It sounds like the author, and their editor, may need to seek help from the employee assistance program.
What is next, a write-up on how to pay less for food by stuffing it in your pockets before you walk out of the market?
You know that there are other countries in the world, right?
This post is ridiculous, I tried this ten years ago and was told by the flight attendant that they could put me in jail for pouring my own drinks on an airplane.
I can't help being disappointed by the tip... There i was, expecting you to tell me that you can actually smoke in the toilets, as long as you keep the cigarette under the closed toilet lid, blow the smoke under that same lid, and flush the toilets as often as possible (tried and tested).
Or I thought you were gonna tell me about that trick to unlock the toilets from the outside (tip: check carefully the metal sign that sticks out of the door and says "toilet").
Or again that picking up a hostess in the plane is very difficult, but that once that the plane has landed it's a completely different game.
But alcohol on a plane... Even Air France has free champagne at the bar in the back of their plane between EU and Asia.
Exactly, what's the big deal?
Every single airline I fly with on journeys over 2 hours offers me free alcohol; Cathay, Singapore, Air NZ, Virgin, even TAM for goodness' sake, can't ply me with enough wine, beer and Bloody Maries. I only fly Economy for work and play.
This must be some kind of US-centric (US carriers and/or US internal flights) problem. As always, the rest of the world seems more civilised.
Overseas airlines are great about this, I had the same experience on Singapore Air. U.S. airlines are horrible. The last flight I had on an American airline, about 10 months ago, gave me 2 cups of water over a 4 hour flight, and that was it. No snack, and of course no free booze. If at all possible, stay away from any American airline!
That's innovation :)
I also like to take in an empty bottle of water that I just chugged (american use of the word not brit) and re-fil it using the fountain. Not cheap but not a big fan of $4.00-$5.00 bottle of water.
They really need to drop the no carrying water rule